Sunday, August 19, 2012

Perrine Poetry Interpretation

As I began reading Perrine's article, I realized that I completely disagree with him.  I truly believe that a "poem is like an ink blot in a Rorschach personality test" (Perrine 1).  Although some students have the same interpretations, almost every student will be looking at the poem from a different perspective and that produces different readings.  Yes, some people have some readings that are pretty crazy, but that is how they interpreted what they read.  Also, the criteria he establishes to determine the validity of a reading is a bit extreme.  Just because the reader has a more complicated or less economical way of explaining the details does not make their opinion wrong.  When a writer writes, they use their imagination, which can make a piece become very complex and very deep.  Thus meaning that the more complex interpretations would be better.

Although I see the author's point when he describes the sunset, I also see the validity in the sea of flowers.  When he says "Again I received not a single correct solution"(Perrine 4), it begs the question, is Perrine the one that does not match up to the rest?  What makes his interpretation correct and everyone else's wrong?  Although he has good reasoning for why his is correct, his reasoning to prove the others incorrect is shoddy at best.  He then continues with the problems that symbols cause, but again I do not agree with his point.  If two people were to guess at the symbol, very seldom would two of them produce the exact same answer.  A little variation will most likely exist, and Perrine does not account for that in his entire work.  Not every human being is exactly the same, and we definitely do not all think the same, thus meaning that there will be variations in the poem interpretations too!

No comments:

Post a Comment