Thursday, November 29, 2012
Frankenstein post 10
In Frankenstein by Mary Shelley, the author uses allusions to compare characters to well known people from history. In this specific cast, this is an allusion to a religious figure. The creature says, "But it is even so; the fallen angel becomes a malignant devil. Yet even that enemy of God and man has friends and associates in his desolation; I am alone." (Shelley, 165). Here he alludes to the devil himself. The angel that turned against God and is now burns in a fiery Hell. The creature views himself as this horrendous and terrible. The creature himself realizes the havoc he has reeked on society as a whole. Also, the havoc he has reeked on the Frankenstein family. I would not agree with his comparison, but he has certainly destroyed an entire family of people. He also made them suffer every step of the way.
Frankenstein post 9
In Frankenstein, by Mary Shelley, we learn, very late in the book, some very important characteristics about Victor's character. We learn that he is almost fearless. In the twenty second chapter, he basically tells us that he does not care if he dies. He says, "I had prepared for my own death, I hastened that of a far dearer victim" (Shelley, 141). He has gotten himself to the point that he does not care if he dies. This is unfathomable for most people, considering that it is abnormal to not value your own life. If this were today's society, Victor would have felt that he was invincible. He would have figured that the creature either would not even try to kill him, or that he could fight him off. The time period of this story, drastically changes the characterization of this character. This could almost be viewed as chivalrous.
Frankenstein post 8
In Frankenstein by Mary Shelley, the author uses foreshadowing through the creature's statements. After Victor destroyed the creature's companion that was almost completed, the creature gets in a heater argument with Victor. He eventually says, "I will be with you on your wedding-night" (Shelley, 123). Victor takes this one way, but I believe the monster means this another way. Victor takes this as a direct personal threat. He thinks that the mobster will kill him on his wedding night. I believe this is incorrect, I believe this monster means that he will kill Victor's wife on their wedding night. Almost like an eye for an eye mentality. Victor destroyed the creature's love, and the creature plans to get back by destroying Victor's love. This is the monster foreshadowing the death of Elizabeth, in my opinion.
Frankenstein post 7
In Frankenstein by Mary Shelley portrays irony through Victor's character. He creates the creature, thus meaning that the creature should be subordinate to him. Like a father and his son. For the most part, the son listens to the father, he may argue from time to time, but he listens eventually. The father may have to set his son straight every once in a while, but this is what childhood is about. Victor and his creation are different. Victor is enslaved to this character, much the opposite of how this relationship should work. The creature tells him what to do, he is almost completely controlled by this creation. The creature says, "Slave, I before reasoned with you, but you have proved yourself unworthy of my condescension. Remember, I have the power..."(Shelley, 122). This is coming from the creature, calling his creator his slave. This creature clearly has control.
Frankenstein Post 6
In Frankenstein by Mary Shelley, one of the major themes is alienation. This is experienced by multiple characters at many different times. I want to focus on one specific example. In the thirteenth chapter, the creature created by Dr. Frankenstein, is displaying this theme. Shelley says, "It was on one of these days, when my cottagers periodically rested from labour-the old man played on his guitar, and the children listened to him..."(Shelley, 82). Here, the monster does not outwardly state that he is experiencing this alienation that I spoke of. Although he doesn't say this, he does show us by how closely he watches this family and how attached he becomes. He is outside this home, watching this family for an extended period of time. He learns their language and when he attempts to interact with them, he gets the same result. He views them as friends, but they don't even know who he is, or even like him for that matter. He is experiencing alienation without even knowing it.
Sunday, November 18, 2012
Frankenstein post 5
In the beginning of this section of Frankenstein, the monster gives off a very demonic vibe. He says, "Do your duty towards me, and i will do mine towards you and the rest of mankind. If you comply with my conditions, I will leave them and you at peace; but if you refuse, I will glut the maw of death, until it be satiated with the blood of your remaining friends. (Shelley, 68). Shelley portrays this monster as someone who intentionally attempts to be scary. This sentence actually led me to believe that the monster did actually kill William ans in turn cause the death of Justine. This all changed as the monster began telling the story. He evokes a sense of pity from the reader for all the hardship he has been put through. After reading about how the monster has to find his own food and how he spent many days without nourishment or something to drink, I felt bad for him. This is definitely connectable to the theme of alienation. This monster lived underneath the house of a poor family for what seems to be quite some time...and all because his creator neglected him? Maybe this creature has a legitimate reason for killing William...was it to get Victor's ?attention?
Frankenstein post 4
In Frankenstein by Mary Shelley, Victor blames himself for two murders, both of which he did not personally commit. He says, "But, I the true murderer, felt the never-dying worm alive in my bosom, which allowed of no hope or consolation." (Shelley, 59). There is not evidence that the monster killed William, but Victor insists that this act was committed by his creation. He repeatedly insists this throughout the 8th chapter. I, however, do not believe this. I think there is another character that committed this murder and led to the death of Justine. I am not sure who it is or how this happened, but I know that Justine murdered William. I also strongly believe that this murder was not committed by the creature fathered by Victor. I am very interested to see if Victor can find evidence to prove his theory about the creature committing the murder. Although it will not bring back either of the two deceased parties, it would console the family and I am also just curious about it.
Frankenstein post 3
In Frankenstein by Mary Shelley, Shelley uses irony in some interesting ways. After Victor has worked so had to create this monster, he feels a bit of creator's remorse. Victor says, "...now that I have finished , the beauty of the dream vanished, and breathless horror and disgust filled my heart." (Shelley, 35). This could be equated to buyers remorse in today's housing market. The thought of buying a new car or house is amazing when a person is looking for a home or test driving cars, but almost without fail, there is some remorse involved when paying for the goods purchased. I can actually relate to this personally. At the beginning of the summer, I decided to purchase a new lawn mower for my lawn care business. I was very excited when I got it and even for a few weeks after. Little did I know, we were going to have the biggest drought in our state's history. I did not end up losing money in the deal, and I certainly did not feel the magnitude of regret that Victor did, but there is still a relatively good connection.
Frankenstein post 2
In Frankenstein by Mary Shelley, Shelley uses allusions very frequently. These allusions help to give a sense of the audience that she wanted to direct her work to. With all of these references, the reader would have to be educated to a relatively high level. If I had to venture a guess, I would say that the reader would have probably needed a college education to understand the book at the time of the book's publishing. In the very early parts of the book, Shelley says, "I imagined that I also might obtain a niche in the temple where the names of Homer and Shakespeare are consecrated" (Shelley, 2). The average person of the era would not be educated enough on Homer or Shakespeare to understand the point of these references. She also makes a reference to Paracelsus and Albertus Magnus. She says, "When I returned home my first care was to procure the whole works of this author, and afterwards of the Paracelsus and Albertus Magnus." (Shelley, 21). She left a superscript next to the reference to Paracelsus and Magnus because of the lack of readers that would understand this reference. In fact, I did not even understand who this reference was alluding to.
Sunday, November 11, 2012
Frankenstein post 1 (Letters)
In Frankenstein by Mary Shelley, many of the letters that are used to being the novel include characterization. Shelley mainly focuses on direct characterization, which means that little if any indirect characterization is used. In the second letter, Shelly writes, "The master is a person of excellent disposition, and is remarkable in the ship for his gentleness and the mildness of his discipline" (Shelley 5). Here Shelley discusses the master's leadership skills and his reputable integrity and courage. The passage continues to talk more about this "master"'s characteristics and his reputation. Shelley then continues characterizing in the fourth letter. She says, "I never saw a more interesting creature; his eyes have generally an expression of wildness, and even madness..." (Shelley 9). This is in reference to the unnamed man they fount floating in the ocean on a chunk of ice. Walton is immediately awestruck by this man because of how complex he seems. He further describes the man and speaks about his mood and attitude referring to it as "melancholy" (Shelley, 10).
Wednesday, October 31, 2012
APO 96225 by Larry Rottman
In APO 96225 by Larry Rottman, Rottman indirectly provides for us an aphorism. The message that I pulled from this is that people make it seem like they care, until the truth comes out. Most times when people approach others, they ask how their day is going or what they are up to, but do people actually care? I don't think so. I agree with Rottman whole heatedly about this. People in our society are just being courteous by asking these questions, but if I were to go on a rant about how terribly my week or day has been, they would just walk away. There is a great example of this in the poem. The parents say, " Son we want you to tell us everything. Everything!" but, he responds by saying, "Today I killed a man. Yesterday, I helped drop napalm on women and children." (Rottman, 846). His parents act like they want to know all the graphic details about his work overseas. This all changes when he actually gives them what they say they want. In this case, I don't blame his parents for not wanting to know about all the people he killed; however, people in real life should genuinely care about what is going on and whats wrong with people around them.
Much Madness is divinest Sense by Emily Dickinson
In Much Madness is divinest Sense by Emily Dickinson, she presents an very interesting paradox. Her proposition is that good sense is insane, and insanity is good sense. This makes absolutely no sense to me, so I will do my best to muddle my way through. She says in the very title, "Much Madness is divinest sense- To a discerning eye..." (Dickinson, 830). She is blatantly saying that crazy people are actually sensible. I honestly thing she might be a bit crazy herself. If she actually believes this, then what exactly does she define as madness, of much madness? Also, what does she classify as sense? She then moves on to say, "Much sense-the starkest Madness...(Dickinson, 830). I think that Emily Dickinson was a little bit crazy when she wrote this poem.
I felt a funeral, in my brain by Emily Dickinson
In I felt a funeral, in my Brain by Emily Dickinson, Dickinson uses imagery to convey her message. She hits on all of the senses except two. She begins with sight by saying, "I felt a Funeral, in my Brain, and Mourners to and fro"(Dickinson, 776). She brings to my mind the sight of all the people mourning at a funeral. This actually reminds me of my father because he always says that at a funeral its easy to tell how many lives the deceased person touched. Just look at how packed the church is, or how long the procession to the cemetery is. She then continues with hearing. She says, "A service, like a drum-Kept beating-beating..."(Dickinson, 776). For me, this image evokes memories form my great grandmother's funeral because there were men there playing bagpipes and drums. Lastly, I found an example of the sense of touch. She says, "And I dropped down, and down-And hit a World at every plunge..." (Dickinson, 776). I cannot find examples of taste and smell in this work, but they could very well be hidden in a deeper meaning that I lack the ability to uncover.
Miss Brill by Katherine Mansfield
In Miss Brill by Katherine Mansfield, the author portrays Miss Brill as nonexistent in society. Everyone around her is interacting with each other but, when Ms. Brill wants to jump in, they all scatter or just don't acknowledge her. The narrator says, "Oh she was so pleased to see him-delighted! She rather thought they were going to meet that afternoon". As she began to talk to him, "he shook his head, lighted a cigarette, slowly breathed a great deep puff into her face" (Mansfield, 184). She is so excited tot see this man, and he rudely blows a puff of smoke in her face. I cannot decide why society does not except her, but I do not think there is an excusable reason to do this to someone. Then towards the end of the poem, a new couple began to sit down beside her. There is not even interaction before the girl says, "Not here, I can't". The man says, "But why? Because of that stupid old thing at the end there?" and he continues with, "Why does she cone here at all-who wants her? Why doesn't she keep her silly old mug at home?" (Mansfield, 186). Clearly, by his second statement, she is known by many people because he does not hesitate to just tear her apart. What exactly could someone do to receive this much hatred and dislike?
Bartleby the Scrivener by Herman Melville
In Bartleby the Scrivener by Herman Melville, the author uses the speaker to characterize himself and the other people that work for him. For example, the lawyer says, "I am a rather elderly man". A few paragraphs later he continues with, "I am a man who from his youth upwards has been filled with a profound conviction that the easiest way of life is the best." (Melville, 642). Here he begins to describe himself and after his digression, he comes back and says that he believes that the easiest way of life is best. I think this describes his views on being rich and owning many material things. He does not say these are bad, but i believe that by his statement, he is saying that he does not want to live this way. He is simply saying that he would prefer to live a simple life, because it is better. He then continues on to describe Turkey, one of his employees. He does so by saying, "Turkey was a short, pursy Englishman of about my own age, that is somewhere not far from sixty." He then continues on to describe Turkey's great work ethic in the morning and how it begins to lag as the day goes on, especially past noon.(Melville, 644). This brief description tells the reader a lot about turkey and his character just by mentioning his lack of work ethic in the evenings and his age.
Wednesday, October 24, 2012
Death, be not proud
In Death, be not Proud by John Donne, Donne offers a very blunt reminder of the fact that death is inevitable, but we will seek eternal life. He says, "Thou art a slave to fate, chance, kings, and desperate men..."(Donne, 971). Here he is saying that death does not pick and choose who dies. We all die at some point, everyone from kings to desperate men. He also mentions that death comes from many different sources. He says, "And dost with poison, war, and sickness dwell" (Donne, 971). He lists a short list of a few places that death can claim us from our earthly dwellings. He then moves to a much more positive note. He says, "One short sleep passed, we wake eternally. And death shall be no more; death, thou shalt die"(Donne, 972). In these closing lines, he is saying that once we die, we will never have to experience it again! Once we pass on to our eternal lives, death will be dead to us!
That Time of Year
In That Time of Year by William Shakespeare, he uses organizational tools like rhyming iambic pentameter and a complex rhyme scheme to keep this piece very organized. He says in the very first line, "That time of year thou mayst in be behold" (Shakespeare, 966). Here he uses his signature iambic pentameter to organize this line of the work. Iambic pentameter is the use of 10 syllables in a line and the syllables alternate stressed and unstressed when being read. This technique gives the poem some rhythm and is somewhat complex to put together. He then ends by saying, "This thou perceivest, which makes thy love more strong, To love that well which thou must leave ere long"(Shakespeare, 966). Here Shakespeare implements a technique called rhyming couplets. This means that he took the last two lines in the poem and instead of following his ABABCDCD... rhyme scheme, he then went to GG. All of these steps put together are used to create a sonnet, something that William Shakespeare was very familiar with. He wrote over 100 Sonnets back in his time.
Crossing the Bar
In Crossing the Bar by Alfred, Lord Tennyson, Tennyson uses an extended metaphor to relate death to the ocean. He relates some nautical terms to simple innuendos about death. He says in line 3, "And may there be no moaning of the bar When i put out to sea," (Tennyson, 886). This is a reference to a sand bar that develops in the exit of a port and all along the ocean due to tide flows and other factors. He relates the crossing of this bar to death. The metaphor continues when he says, "When that which drew from the boundless deep Turns again home." (Tennyson, 886). Here he is making a reference to the area beyond the sand bar or the vast ocean that is essentially bottomless. He ties this back to death because when we die, we go to heaven with is a very vast place. Heaven is also our new home when our earthly life comes to an end, much like the water's "home" is in the ocean. Later in the poem, there is also an allusion to God, and seeing Him when the speaker enters heaven.
The Lottery
In The Lottery by Shirley Jackson, Jackson presents somewhat of a play on words and ideas throughout her work. I find some of this to be ironic to modern day readers because there are completely rational explanations for many of the events that occur. Primarily, the biggest play on words is the title. The Lottery gives any modern American the impression that a large sum of money is at stake and they need to buy a ticket! Unfortunately, this is not the case with this specific "Lottery". Before I get to the real kicker, I would like to point out the other thing that i found ironic. Towards the beginning of the story Jackson says, "Bobby martin had already stuffed his pockets full of stones, and the other boys soon followed by his example, selecting the smoothest and roundest stones..." (Jackson, 264). When I read it, I thought that this was kids doing that they do, simply playing with some rocks making a pile of them and playing around. I was sorely mistaken(no pun intended). These innocent little boys were not just playing with these rocks, they were making a nice neat pile of them so that they could stone whoever "won" this "lottery" they were holding. I found this ironic, because the author never gives any indication as to what then end brings, she just continues along her merry way telling a story about stoning someone who drew a piece of paper with a black dot on it.
A Rose for Emily
In A Rose for Emily by William Faulkner, Faulkner leaves parts of the story up to the reader's imagination. He lets the reader make their own inferences as to what happened. He also really never gives a plain answer to some questions that the story poses. An example would be when he says, "as we had expected all along, within three days Homer Baron was back in town. A neighbor say the Negro man admit him at the kitchen door at dusk one evening. And that was the last we saw of Homer Baron" (Faulkner, 287). In this part of the story, Homer had finished his work fixing the streets; however, he still came back and went to Miss Emily's home again. The odd part is that this is the last time anyone say him alive. The story only gets better, they found his body 40 years later in Miss Emily's home and it was decomposed. Also, laying beside him, was a pillow with hair matching the color of Miss Emily's and an indentation from a head in the pillow. The author never explicitly says that she was the one that had lain there, but I am of the opinion that she did. This is because there is no other plausible explanation as to who had lain there and what a piece of hair matching hers was doing there. Again, this was all inferred and is merely an opinion, Faulkner never explicitly states it. This is also just one of many examples in this story.
Wednesday, October 3, 2012
The Glass Menagerie post 5
In The Glass Menagerie by Tennessee Williams, there is an interesting external conflict between Amanda and Tom and another conflict between Amanda and Laura. I would say that the cause of both of these conflicts is Amanda for the most part. Honestly, she does pretty much the sane things to both of her children, except Tom's conflict is more extreme. First of all, Amanda tries to control her children's lives. She treats them like they are still little kids, except they are both grown up. An example would be when she says, "You can't put in a day's work on an empty stomach. You've got ten minutes-don't gulp! Drinking too-hot liquids makes cancer of the stomach...Put cream in it."(Williams, 1250). In my opinion, if Tom is old enough to support his mother and sister on a financial level, then he is old enough to decide how fast he wants to drink his coffee. Amanda consistently nags her children throughout the entirety of the play. Also, I believe that the conflict between her and Tom ultimately drove him to leaving them. Her conflict with Laura is less severe, but Amanda still nags Laura to death. In my opinion, Laura and Tom are both saints for putting up with their mother as long as they do.
The Glass Menagerie post 4
In The Glass Menagerie by Tennessee Williams, the characters are characterized in very interesting ways. He uses the characters to characterize themselves in some situations. He also uses other characters to characterize some at points as well. When Tom says "I go to the movies because - I like adventure. Adventure is something I don't have much of at work, so I go to the movies." (Williams, 1252), he characterizes himself. He tells the reader that he does not like his job at all because he likes adventure. He also hints at his hatred of his job through out the play when he make sarcastic remarks about his warehouse job. Tom also characterizes Laura at some points in the play. When discussing with Amanda about the lack of gentleman-callers, Tom makes the point that Laura is crippled and that she is not like other teenage girls. This is the first time I remember reading that she was crippled. I did figure out that she was weird when she played with the glass figurines, but Tom was the first to mention her being crippled. I find this interesting because Tom does this as a character, not as the narrator as I would have expected.
The Glass Menagerie post 3
In The Glass Menagerie by Tennessee Williams, there are many symbols used. These include the magician escaping the coffin without removing a nail, the transparent fourth wall, and the glass figures. The magician escaping the coffin without removing a nail symbolizes two things. The first being how their father escaped from the family, he just up and left them. The second is how Tom longs to escape and how hard it will be for him to escape his mother's hold on him. In the stage directions, Williams says, "The interior scene is played as though viewed through soundproof glass." (Williams, 1288). This is meant to symbolize Tom not being with his family, and the distance that it between them now. The last symbol, the glass figures, is explicitly explained to us by Tom early on. Basically, he says that they symbolize Laura and her timid and fragile personality. This makes sense and is an interesting comparison because Laura does tend to walk on eggshells as some might say. She is a very fragile person and i think this could also be attributed to the way her mother treats her like a child.
Tuesday, October 2, 2012
The Glass Menagerie post 2
In The Glass Menagerie by Tenessee Williams, Tom begins to feel some very serious guilt after he leaves his sister and mother. The interesting part is that he does not feel too terrible about leaving his mother. However, he feels guilty for leaving his sister with his mother. This characterizes both Amanda and Tom in different ways, and says a lot about the external conflict that takes place. This characterizes Amanda in the sense that she almost drove Tom to the point on insanity. She was constantly nagging both her children, even though they are adults. An example would be when she says, "You can't put in a day's work on an empty stomach. You've got ten minutes-don't gulp! Drinking too-hot liquids makes cancer of the stomach...Put cream in it."(Williams, 1250). Throughout that entire line, she never stops nagging him, and he is a grown man! As terrible as this sounds, I can honestly understand why he feels no remorse for leaving his mother behind. I also see why he feels so bad about leaving Laura with their mother because of all the nagging all the time!
The Glass Menagerie post 1
Throughout The Glass Menagerie by Tennessee Williams, Tom is compared to his father by his mother and sometimes by himself. Amanda says, "More and more you remind me of your father! He was out all hours without explanation!-Then left! Goodbye!" (Williams, 1253). Here Amanda is referencing multiple things that worry her about her son. Her primary reference is him wanting to escape from their house. He has a great job offer which would involve leaving home. Although this offer is great, his mother tells him that he will be just like his father if he leaves before his sister, Laura, is through school. Her second reference in this quote is his frequent trips to "the movies". She hates that he is always leaving to go out for hours every night. She also frowns upon the fact that he gets home at an ungodly hour most nights. Tom compares himself to his father when he says, "I descended the steps of the fire'escape for the last time and followed from then on, in my father's footsteps..." (Williams, 1288). He says this in reference to him leaving the house for the last time, much like his father did when he walked out on him and the rest of the family.
Wednesday, September 19, 2012
The drunkard by Frank O'Connor
In The Drunkard by Frank O'Connor, he uses irony to create a very interesting work. He uses lots of irony throughout, but he specifically says, "Hello, he said in a fairly good-humored tone, as if he were prepared to consider it a joke, even if it was in bad taste" (O'Connor, 347). Here father is looking for his second beer that he ordered, but he can't seem to find it. This is due to the fact that Larry drank it after he finished his lemonade. Father had no idea until he looked at Larry and realized that he was drunk. Not only did he not realize that it was Larry all along, but he was also looking around in an accusatory fashion.
Although this was a terribly accident, the mother seems to be in relatively good spirits after her initial shock. I find this to be ironic because most mothers would not be. I know my mom would be very mad at my dad is he took me to a pub when i was 9 and did not realize that i drank i pint of beer. She referred to the whole situation as an act of God so that Larry could be his father's guardian angel.
Although this was a terribly accident, the mother seems to be in relatively good spirits after her initial shock. I find this to be ironic because most mothers would not be. I know my mom would be very mad at my dad is he took me to a pub when i was 9 and did not realize that i drank i pint of beer. She referred to the whole situation as an act of God so that Larry could be his father's guardian angel.
Tuesday, September 18, 2012
The Joy of Cooking by Elaine Magarrell
In The Joy of Cooking by Elaine Magarrell, she uses some very interesting images to characterize her brother and sister. She uses her sister's tongue and her brother's heart. She begins by referring to the tongue, and says, "I have prepared my sister's tongue, scrubbed and skinned it, trimmed the roots, small bones, and gristle."(Magarrell, LN:1-3). She is very upfront and direct about describing her sister. From her description, i get a sense that her sister is some what of a smart mouthed and sarcastic person. Although she was very direct about her sister's description, she just flat out tells us that her brother has a "firm and rather dry"(Magarrell, LN:9) heart. I think she is being relatively literal about this description as well. He seems like someone who has no compassion for others and who just generally does not care about others. Some might use the term jerk to characterize her brother. All in all, I find this poem to be very weird, and the writer to be a bit demented in the way that she described serving her siblings body parts to people on a platter.
Those Winter Days by Robert Hayden
In Those Winter Days by Robert Hayden, the author expresses how his father showed his love for his son through his actions. Hayden says, "I'd wake and hear the cold splintering, breaking. When the rooms were ward, he'd call, and slowly I would rise and dress..."(Hayden, 781). Here he explains how he did not get up until his father called him to wake up. This was not because his father was a dictator. It was because his father wanted to make sure the house was warm from the previous night before his son woke up. Such a simple, but selfless gesture on his father's part.
He also makes an allusion near the end in the last stanza. He says, "...and polished my good shoes as well."(Hayden, 782). Here he alludes to the fact that he was going to attend church. I concluded this because i could not think of anywhere else a young boy would wear his "good shoes" on a Sunday morning.
Once Upon a Time by Nadine Gordimer
In Once Upon a Time by Nadine Gordimer, Gordimer has some irony that is extended throughout the entire work. She begins the fairy tale by saying " I don't write children's stories..."(Gordimer, 231). However, she still calls is a fairy tale and fairy tales are clearly written for children to read. She also goes with this "fairy tale" idea when she describes the neighborhood at then end. She says, "In a hosed, in a suburb, in a city, there were a man and his wife who loved each other very much and were living happily ever after..."(Gordimer, 232). This line, in conjunction with man others, makes it clear that this is the setting of a fairy tale...for children. The fairy tale idea stops with the setting though. She talks about robberies and people breaking into houses, which are not topics commonly used in fairy tales for children. Not only does she talk about minor crimes like the ones previously mentioned, but she also talks about riots. She then gets into how the house maids could quite possibly be the ones committing the crimes as well as the gardeners... My point to all this is that this is not a typical fairy tale, and many of the elements used are very ironic when they are considered to be part of a fairy tale.
A Worn Path by Eudora Welty
In A Worn Path by Eudora Welty, we get a very descriptive characterization of Phoenix Jackson on the very first page. The entire second paragraph is a direct characterization of her physical attributes. Welty says, "Her skin had a pattern all its own of numberless branching wrinkles and as though a whole little tree stood in the middle of her forehead." (Welty, 223). Even earlier than that, we learn little details like the fact that she is African American and that she walks slowly. The writer was certainly not trying to disguise her appearance at all. I also found it interesting how Welty indirectly led us into her lack of memory by having Phoenix ignore the nurse and the clerk attending to the desk. We also learn something about her from the journey that she made to the doctor's office. The medicine she got must be important to her and her grandson. This is evident for many reasons. One is the frequency of her trips, and the other is that she hikes through the woods and across a creek to get to this medicine. Her grandson must NEED this medicine if she is going to those lengths to get her hands on it.
Thursday, September 13, 2012
A Raisin in the Sun 5
As I was reading the end of A Raisin in the Sun, I realized that there is more to the fifth note taking guide question than meets the eye. In an earlier post, I said Mama just ruled the house, she controlled everyone's lives even her daughter in law. Although this analysis is correct, there is more to be said about this question because I never addressed the problems that the older generation had to deal with. I think Mama sees all of the younger people in the house taking things for granted that she had to work very hard for. Here is an example, it is like two people working to buy a house and pay it off. When they die, they will pass the home down to their children and if one chooses to live there, they will take it for granted. They never worked for the house and they never paid a dime for it. This home was handed to them by their parents. A person can not truly appreciate something unless they have to work towards it, or they invest their own money to purchase it. Walter says sarcastically, "So that's the peace and comfort you went out and bought for us today!"(Hansberry, 490). I would say this characterizes him as an ungrateful brat, but that is just my opinion. More to my point, he does not have any appreciation for it. This has two reasons, first of all, it is not what he wanted, and secondly, he did not invest a dime into it and he did not work for it at all. True appreciation for things comes from hard work and sacrifice. Mama notices that, but will the others?
A Raisin in the Sun 4
In A Raisin in the Sun by Lorraine Hansberry, there are a handful of very distinct and obvious allusions that point to different documents and people throughout history. Some of these allusions include a reference to Tarzan, a line from the movie The Lion King, a reference to Adam and Eve, and lastly a biblical reference from the gospels. In her reference to Tarzan, Mama says, "...I think its so sad the way our American Negroes don't know nothing about Africa 'cept Tarzan and all that."(Hansberry, 467). Here she is saying that she is disappointing that African-Americans don't seem to care about their culture or roots and all they know about their homeland is the main character, from Tarzan of the Apes. Hansberry also makes an allusion to the movie The Lion King when Walter and Beneatha seem to be joking around about their culture and background. The phrase, "OWIMOWEH" comes straight from the song The Lion Sleeps Tonight in popular Disney film. She also makes two biblical references. One being the reference to Adam and Eve, and the other being a reference to the number of coins Judas Iscariot received for betraying Jesus. I also think that the reference to the coins symbolizes how the family was affected by this offer and how terrible they thought it was.
Wednesday, September 12, 2012
A Raisin in the Sun 3
In A Raisin in the Sun by Lorraine Hansberry, I would say that there are two characters that seem to be seeking a better way of life. These characters have a completely different approach to this. Mama does so by attempting to make life easier for herself and the rest of the family, mainly by buying a house instead of the apartment that they are living in. When she tells Travis that she bought a house, he says, "Yeah-I always wanted to live in a house."(Hansberry, 489). He is excited to finally have a bedroom instead of the couch in the living room! I think Mama's goal is not to better herself, but to better the family by giving them a home to live in. The other character interested in seeking a better way of life is Walter. He blatantly says "A job. Mama, a job? I open and close car doors all day long. I drive a man around in his limousine and I say, "yes, sir; no, sir; very good, sir; shall I take the drive, sir?" Mama that ain't no kind of job...that ain't nothing at all..."(Hansberry, 475). Walter's approach to a better way of life is much more self centered. He has his family in mine throughout, but, he seems to only be worried about HIMSELF and HIS job. I honestly believe Walter's ultimate goal is to set himself forward by using the insurance money for his business scheme and eventually, when the time comes, his entire family will benefit!
A Raisin in the Sun 2
In A Raisin in the Sun by Lorraine Hansberry, we seem to get a better idea of the answer the fifth question on the note taking guide. The question posed asks us to discuss how the family deals with the generation gap between all the characters in A Raisin in the Sun. I think this question has a very simple answer, Mama controls the the house. She controls every member of the family, some to a different degree, but she clearly has authority over all the members of the household. Primarily, I would say she controls the life of Walter. For example Mama says, "Ain's nobody said you wasn't grown. But you are still in my house and my presence. And as long as you are-you'll talk to your wife civil. Now sit down."(Hansberry, 473). Mama shows her authority over Walter very clearly here, and he resists at first, but complies after Mama is adamant about sitting down. Mama also shows her authoritative position very distinctly and clearly when she speaks to Travis. She says, "...Travis, baby, run next door and ask Miss Johnson to please let me have a little kitchen cleanser. This here can is as empty as Jacob's kettle."(Hansberry, 469). Even though Ruth is clearly not her child or her grandchild, Mama still acts as if she has authority over her. Mama says, "Who told you [Ruth] to get up?"(Hansberry, 469). I understand that she is pregnant and all, but Mama seems to address her just as a mother would address her own children.
A Raisin in the Sun 1
In A Raisin in the Sun by Lorraine Hansberry, I believe that even in the first thirty pages, question eight on our note taking guide can be answered with a high degree of certainty. The question posed is about finding two characters in a literary work that are opposites in views, beliefs, and philosophy. I believe that Walter and Ruth fit this profile. In my notes, I said that I noticed that Walter seemed to be the stereotypical "fun parent" and Ruth seemed to be the stereotypical "strict parent". For example, "Travis: This is the morning we are supposed to bring the fifty cents to school. Ruth: I ain't got no fifty cents this morning. Travis: The teacher say we have to. Ruth: I don't care what the teacher say, I ain't got it..."(Hansberry, 438) In this passage, Ruth is very stingy with the family's funds and is very blunt about not being able to afford to give Travis the fifty cents he asked for. To contrast, "Walter: In fact, here is an extra fifty cents...Buy yourself some fruit today-or take a taxicab to school or something!"(Hansberry, 441) On the other hand, Walter reached in his pocket and produces double the money without a problem. We also learn later that Ruth will not let her son go carry groceries for shoppers at the grocery store to earn a little extra money, but here again, Walter does not care what Travis does. Certainly as this story continues, we will learn more about these two contrasting characters, but as of not, they are almost polar opposites.
Wednesday, August 29, 2012
Interpreter of Maladies by Jhumpa Lahiri
In Interpreter of Maladies by Jhumpa Lahiri, a very key literary technique is the use of situational irony. Throughout the entire story, Mr. Kapasi and Mr. Das grow more and more similar. The first similarity in men is that they both teach in some form or another. Mr. Kapasi uses his tours to teach people, and Mr. Das teaches a class about science in a middle school. Both very different from each other, however they are also very closely related. I then realized that the men are alike in yet another way. Their wives do not love them. Mr. Kapasi was placed into an arranged marriage with his wife, which never turns out well because the people do not actually love each other. For Mr. Das,I would say the lack of love that his wife has for him and his family is evident in many places, but one struck me the most. Lahiri says "Mrs. Das reached into her straw bag and pulled out a bottle of colorless nail polish, which she proceeded to stroke on the tip of her index finger. The little girl stuck out a hand. 'Mine to. Mommy, do mine too.' ' Leave me alone,' Mrs. Das said, blowing on her nail and turning her body slightly. ' You're making me mess up.'"(Lahiri). This struck me the most for many reasons. The first being that my mother would NEVER have said something like that to either of her daughters when they were little, nor any of us. The second being that she does it in such a rude way. I don't really see how Mr. Kapasi appreciated her as much as he did. Back to my point on situational irony...these two examples are great, because yes, they realize the first; however neither of them really realize that they are similar in the second way.
Everyday use by Alice Walker
In Everyday Use by Alice Walker, the most important and crucial literary technique used is characterization. The narrator switches between direct and indirect, but she uses the two together in an amazing fashion. She says, "In real life, I am a big-boned woman with rough, man-working hands...I can kill and clean a hog as mercilessly as a man."(Walker). Here she is using direct characterization to describe her stature and some other personal attributes. She also refers to her ability to clean hogs. This seems to be something she is quite proud of! The author later uses direct characterization again, but not to describe herself. She says, "Dee is lighter than Maggie, with nicer hair and a fuller figure. She's a woman now, though sometimes I forget."(Walker). Here the author describes the stature of Dee, and compares her to Maggie. The way Walker uses these characterizations is very fluent, she is not bold about how she explains them.
Toads by Philip Larkin
In Toads by Philip Larkin, one of the things that struck me right off the bat was the structure. He has a very specific rhyme scheme that i would say contributes to the poem's overall flow and organization. This rhyme scheme has a pattern ABABCDCD... etc. He has a very specific structure with stanzas of 4 lines called quatrains. He also italicizes key words like "work", "starves", and the phrase "Stuff your pension" (Larkin) to help communicate their importance to the poem's overall meaning.
Larkin also brings a very powerful message to the reader throughout this poem. I believe that his message that money is not everything. People are obsessed with their jobs and work, but their lives are not fulfilled. This hits pretty close to home for me because I am very much one who obsesses over work. A few summers ago, I did not spend a day just relaxing. I was either working for my company, Alfery Lawncare, or I was at cross country practice, neither of which were very much fun.
Larkin also brings a very powerful message to the reader throughout this poem. I believe that his message that money is not everything. People are obsessed with their jobs and work, but their lives are not fulfilled. This hits pretty close to home for me because I am very much one who obsesses over work. A few summers ago, I did not spend a day just relaxing. I was either working for my company, Alfery Lawncare, or I was at cross country practice, neither of which were very much fun.
Hazel tells Laverne
In Hazel Tells LaVerne by Katharyn Howd Machan, the use of satire to connect to The Frog Prince is a crucial part to the poem's message. In class, I referred to this as a more realistic attempt at the story of The Frog Prince. However, now I am seeing it as more of a satirical approach on Machan's part. Towards the end of the poem, she says "ya little green pervert" (Machan), a very odd way of viewing the frog, but most would find it to be funny as well. She also uses a toilet as a substitute for the well that was traditionally part of the fairy tale. I would say this is used to make the poem a much more modern attempt at this old tale.
A central theme that I picked up on while reading this poem seems to be very important. I think that her main message is in reference to the blue collar community and she is saying that they don't believe in fairy tales. They are just not in the realm of possibilities for a person of that class. The work so hard for what they have, that they can't imagine getting something handed to them like that.
A central theme that I picked up on while reading this poem seems to be very important. I think that her main message is in reference to the blue collar community and she is saying that they don't believe in fairy tales. They are just not in the realm of possibilities for a person of that class. The work so hard for what they have, that they can't imagine getting something handed to them like that.
Tuesday, August 28, 2012
Dream Deferred P.805-806
In Dream Deferred by Langston Hughes, the use of similes is crucial to the poem's message. In the poem, literally every single line has part of a comparison in it and they are all very deep and powerful. Hughes says "Does it dry up like a raisin in the sun?"(Hughes). The other similes also contribute to the general mood of the poem, because none of them are positive. They are all negative and reference something sad or unhappy. To close the poem, Hughes says "Or does it explode?"(Hughes). This line stands alone, in italics at the bottom of the poem. I think he separates it for a reason. This is the mos profound statement he makes for more than one reason. The first being that is is the most severe outcome, and the second being that it is the only one that I believe to be true. This is very powerful to me because i have had dreams that i did not act on, and the opportunity was swept away. This explosion is a very creative way to look at a scenario like this.
Sunday, August 19, 2012
Perrine Poetry Interpretation
As I began reading Perrine's article, I realized that I completely disagree with him. I truly believe that a "poem is like an ink blot in a Rorschach personality test" (Perrine 1). Although some students have the same interpretations, almost every student will be looking at the poem from a different perspective and that produces different readings. Yes, some people have some readings that are pretty crazy, but that is how they interpreted what they read. Also, the criteria he establishes to determine the validity of a reading is a bit extreme. Just because the reader has a more complicated or less economical way of explaining the details does not make their opinion wrong. When a writer writes, they use their imagination, which can make a piece become very complex and very deep. Thus meaning that the more complex interpretations would be better.
Although I see the author's point when he describes the sunset, I also see the validity in the sea of flowers. When he says "Again I received not a single correct solution"(Perrine 4), it begs the question, is Perrine the one that does not match up to the rest? What makes his interpretation correct and everyone else's wrong? Although he has good reasoning for why his is correct, his reasoning to prove the others incorrect is shoddy at best. He then continues with the problems that symbols cause, but again I do not agree with his point. If two people were to guess at the symbol, very seldom would two of them produce the exact same answer. A little variation will most likely exist, and Perrine does not account for that in his entire work. Not every human being is exactly the same, and we definitely do not all think the same, thus meaning that there will be variations in the poem interpretations too!
Although I see the author's point when he describes the sunset, I also see the validity in the sea of flowers. When he says "Again I received not a single correct solution"(Perrine 4), it begs the question, is Perrine the one that does not match up to the rest? What makes his interpretation correct and everyone else's wrong? Although he has good reasoning for why his is correct, his reasoning to prove the others incorrect is shoddy at best. He then continues with the problems that symbols cause, but again I do not agree with his point. If two people were to guess at the symbol, very seldom would two of them produce the exact same answer. A little variation will most likely exist, and Perrine does not account for that in his entire work. Not every human being is exactly the same, and we definitely do not all think the same, thus meaning that there will be variations in the poem interpretations too!
Wednesday, August 8, 2012
Gatsby 15 (pgs 170-180)
As the final chapter of The Great Gatsby came to a close, there were multiple things that caught my attention. The first being that no one attended Gatsby's funeral. The man from the library came to the cemetery, but not a soul came to attend his funeral. Like I said previously, he was so hospitable to so many people, and none of them had the respect to attend his funeral ceremony. Nick said, "The minister glanced several times at his watch, so I took him aside and asked him to wait for half an hour. But it wasn't any use. Nobody came" (Fitzgerald, 174).
All in all, I would say that F. Scott Fitzgerald did an incredible job with this novel. From start to finish, the reader was engaged and drawn to the work. I am not much of a reader at all, but this is one book that i actually wanted to sit down and finish. Although i did not expect Wilson to be the one that killed Gatsby, it was definitely a very interesting twist that drew me in deeper to the novel. I would also like to note the expert integration of figurative language and the use of irony in this novel. It seemed to me that almost every word or sentence had a deeper meaning, some of which i obviously did not pick up on, but it was incredible the way this novel was crafted!
All in all, I would say that F. Scott Fitzgerald did an incredible job with this novel. From start to finish, the reader was engaged and drawn to the work. I am not much of a reader at all, but this is one book that i actually wanted to sit down and finish. Although i did not expect Wilson to be the one that killed Gatsby, it was definitely a very interesting twist that drew me in deeper to the novel. I would also like to note the expert integration of figurative language and the use of irony in this novel. It seemed to me that almost every word or sentence had a deeper meaning, some of which i obviously did not pick up on, but it was incredible the way this novel was crafted!
Gatsby 14 (pgs 158-169)
As I move into the ninth and final chapter of Fitzgerald's The Great Gatsby, I learned that i was a bit off in my last post. I assumed that since there was suicide in the last book, that this one would follow suit. Also, the pool thing still seems a bit suspicious to me, but then again maybe I am just reading too far into it.
Also, there was a bit of irony there, for me at least. I was obviously not expecting Wilson to be the one that murdered Gatsby. I had honestly forgotten about the fact that Wilson concluded that Gatsby was the owner of the car. However, the irony does not stop there. Mr. Wilson does not know that Daisy was the one that was driving the car. He killed a man, thinking that he was seeking revenge, but he got the wrong person.
Also, one would think that Gatsby's funeral would be backed beyond belief due to the tremendous amount of hospitality he showed to everyone that came to his parties, but Nick has trouble finding one man. Nick says "I'll get somebody for you, Gatsby. Don't worry. Just trust me and I'll get somebody for you..." (Fitzgerald 164).
Also, there was a bit of irony there, for me at least. I was obviously not expecting Wilson to be the one that murdered Gatsby. I had honestly forgotten about the fact that Wilson concluded that Gatsby was the owner of the car. However, the irony does not stop there. Mr. Wilson does not know that Daisy was the one that was driving the car. He killed a man, thinking that he was seeking revenge, but he got the wrong person.
Also, one would think that Gatsby's funeral would be backed beyond belief due to the tremendous amount of hospitality he showed to everyone that came to his parties, but Nick has trouble finding one man. Nick says "I'll get somebody for you, Gatsby. Don't worry. Just trust me and I'll get somebody for you..." (Fitzgerald 164).
Gatsby 13 (pgs 146-157)
As chapter eight of Fitzgerald's The Great Gatsby opens, Nick goes to Gatsby's house as dawn approaches to see what happened the night before. Nothing happened and Gatsby tells him that he waited until 4 am. Fitzgerald then throws in a little foreshadowing when the gardener comes in. He says, "I'm going to drain the pool today, Mr. Gatsby. Leaves'll start falling pretty soon, and there is always trouble with the pipes." and Gatsby responds with "Don't do it to-day" (Fitzgerald, 153). I feel like Gatsby might use the pool to kill himself. I just have a gut feeling that if he had not used the pool the entire summer, then there was always next year. There is really no good reason to keep it open.
Gatsby also makes Nick late for work because they lose track of time. However, Nick did not seem particularly interested in working today anyway. Another odd thing happens in this same section. Jordan calls Nick to go on a date, and he says "I want to see you", but then he says "No-I don't think so this afternoon" (Fitzgerald, 155). So does he want to see her or not? He seems to become more indecisive as the novel continues.
Gatsby also makes Nick late for work because they lose track of time. However, Nick did not seem particularly interested in working today anyway. Another odd thing happens in this same section. Jordan calls Nick to go on a date, and he says "I want to see you", but then he says "No-I don't think so this afternoon" (Fitzgerald, 155). So does he want to see her or not? He seems to become more indecisive as the novel continues.
Gatsby 12 (pgs 131-145)
Tom and Gatsby are still going at it as we move through the end of the seventh chapter of F. Scott Fitzgerald's The Great Gatsby. As they continue, Tom tells Daisy to go ahead and leave with Mr. Gatsby and he and the others will follow along later. On their drive home, they pass Wilson's garage and there is a wreck on the road near there. Tom ironically says, "That's good. Wilson'll have a little business at last." (Fitzgerald, 137). Little does he know, that his mistress, Myrtle Wilson, was killed in a car accident. He also is not aware of the fact that his wife was driving Gatsby's car back from New York and that is who Myrtle was hit by. I would say this might be the most irony any author could fit into a situation...
After Daisy and Gatsby left, Tom offers whiskey to Jordan and Nick, and nick randomly says "No...I just remembered that today's my birthday" (Fitzgerald, 135). Which poses a very simple question, how exactly do you forget that it is your birthday? Maybe they were not really celebrated as much back then? I'm not really sure, but i think it is a bit unreasonable for someone to just forget their birthday...
After Daisy and Gatsby left, Tom offers whiskey to Jordan and Nick, and nick randomly says "No...I just remembered that today's my birthday" (Fitzgerald, 135). Which poses a very simple question, how exactly do you forget that it is your birthday? Maybe they were not really celebrated as much back then? I'm not really sure, but i think it is a bit unreasonable for someone to just forget their birthday...
Gatsby 11 (pgs 119-130)
As the action continues in F. Scott Fitzgerald's The Great Gatsby, we finally see a side of compassion from Tom Buchanan. When he is speaking to Wilson at his garage, he says "I'll let you have the car...I'll send it over tomorrow afternoon"(Fitzgerald 124). He finally realizes the pain and anguish that he has put Wilson through because he is experiencing it first hand. Now his own wife is having an affair right under his nose, and he realizes how powerless and helpless it makes a man feel.
There is also a bit of dramatic irony in the same scene of the book. Myrtle Wilson is not outside with Tom and her husband, but she is upstairs looking out a window at the group. She is staring intently at the car, but she does not focus on Tom. Instead she is staring at Jordan Baker because she thinks she is Tom's wife.
Later in the hotel room, Tom begins to get into it with Gatsby, but instead of getting hot tempered like Tom, Gatsby keeps his cool and plays along. Tom poses an interesting question though. what is with all this "Old Sport" (Fitzgerald 127) stuff that Gatsby always says?
There is also a bit of dramatic irony in the same scene of the book. Myrtle Wilson is not outside with Tom and her husband, but she is upstairs looking out a window at the group. She is staring intently at the car, but she does not focus on Tom. Instead she is staring at Jordan Baker because she thinks she is Tom's wife.
Later in the hotel room, Tom begins to get into it with Gatsby, but instead of getting hot tempered like Tom, Gatsby keeps his cool and plays along. Tom poses an interesting question though. what is with all this "Old Sport" (Fitzgerald 127) stuff that Gatsby always says?
Monday, August 6, 2012
Gatsby 10 (pgs 105-118)
As Fitzgerald's The Great Gatsby continues on, Gatsby worries about Daisy after the party. He complains to Nick that she did not have any fun. Which is only partially true. She had a blast when she was with him, but the party in general was not great.
Gatsby then attends dinner with Nick at Tom and Daisy's. As Nick and Jordan casually talk, Gatsby and Daisy can't seem to hide their love for each other. When Jordan questioned her about it, Daisy's response was "You kiss Nick too" (Fitzgerald 116). After Tom's phone call with his mistress, they decide to go out to New Your City for the day.
So to answer my previous question, the infidelity does continue. I also find it quite disgusting that Daisy chose to do so in their own home...I mean come on, really?
Gatsby then attends dinner with Nick at Tom and Daisy's. As Nick and Jordan casually talk, Gatsby and Daisy can't seem to hide their love for each other. When Jordan questioned her about it, Daisy's response was "You kiss Nick too" (Fitzgerald 116). After Tom's phone call with his mistress, they decide to go out to New Your City for the day.
So to answer my previous question, the infidelity does continue. I also find it quite disgusting that Daisy chose to do so in their own home...I mean come on, really?
Gatsby 9 (pgs 93-104)
Mid way through the sixth chapter of Fitzgerald's The Great Gatsby, the meeting between Gatsby and Daisy improves from the poor start. It improves to the point that Nick feels the need to leave the two of them alone for the rest of the evening. Which begs the question, will the infidelity continue? Will there be an affair that takes place?
We then get the real story of Gatsby's past. He was born to the name James Gatz, and has not been wealthy all of his life. We also are introduced to a new character, Dan Cody, who was Gatsby's mentor when he was just out of school. When Cody died, he left Gatsby $25,000, but Cody's wife somehow kept the money, and from that moment on, Gatsby vowed to be a wealthy man for the rest of his life. He says "He never understood the legal device that was used against him, but what remained of the millions went intact to Ella Kaye" (Fitzgerald 100).
Fitzgerald then throws in some irony. Tom decided to stop by Gatsby's after a ride one day with a few friends. He stayed at Gatsby's for a drink and is concerned when Gatsby tells him that he knows Daisy quite well. This then makes me wonder, how can Tom be concerned about his wife having a possible affair, when he is doing the exact same thing behind her back...so does he not deserve to be cheated on?
We then get the real story of Gatsby's past. He was born to the name James Gatz, and has not been wealthy all of his life. We also are introduced to a new character, Dan Cody, who was Gatsby's mentor when he was just out of school. When Cody died, he left Gatsby $25,000, but Cody's wife somehow kept the money, and from that moment on, Gatsby vowed to be a wealthy man for the rest of his life. He says "He never understood the legal device that was used against him, but what remained of the millions went intact to Ella Kaye" (Fitzgerald 100).
Fitzgerald then throws in some irony. Tom decided to stop by Gatsby's after a ride one day with a few friends. He stayed at Gatsby's for a drink and is concerned when Gatsby tells him that he knows Daisy quite well. This then makes me wonder, how can Tom be concerned about his wife having a possible affair, when he is doing the exact same thing behind her back...so does he not deserve to be cheated on?
Gatsby 8 (pgs 81-92)
After the conclusion of Nicks meeting with Jordan, The Great Gatsby by F. Scott Fitzgerald continues to throw out surprises. As Nick approaches the street, he thinks his house is on fire, but it just Gatsby lighting up the entire block. Nick then proceeds to mention that he spoke with Jordan, and is willing to invite Daisy over to see him in a few days, and Gatsby is quite excited and nervous! Gatsby then fires back asking Nick about his income and he also offers him a job. I can't decide if Nick was smart to decline or if he passed up the business opportunity of a lifetime... On one hand, Gatsby seems like he is dealing with some pretty nasty people, but on the other hand, he obviously knows what he is doing as far as being a businessman goes.
The meeting with Daisy was a bit ironic to me. I expected her to be nervous and embarrassed and not want to talk, but it was Gatsby who was. He says "This is a terrible mistake...a terrible, terrible mistake" (Fitzgerald 87). He has been thinking about this meeting for years, and he seems to have planned it out down to the most minute details. I don'd understand how he gets cold feet after this much thought and planning.
The meeting with Daisy was a bit ironic to me. I expected her to be nervous and embarrassed and not want to talk, but it was Gatsby who was. He says "This is a terrible mistake...a terrible, terrible mistake" (Fitzgerald 87). He has been thinking about this meeting for years, and he seems to have planned it out down to the most minute details. I don'd understand how he gets cold feet after this much thought and planning.
Gatsby 7 (pgs 73-80)
As the story of Fitzgerald's The Great Gatsby continues, I am starting to get the feeling that the source of Gatsby's money is an illegitimate business of some sort. While at lunch, Nick met Mr. Wolfsheim, the gambler that fixed the 1919 World Series game. Nick was completely caught off guard by this response, and this is precisely what makes me suspicious of Mr. Gatsby's wealth. When Nick made an inquiry into why Mr. Wolfsheim wasn't in jail, Gatsby replied, "They can't get him, old sport. He's a smart man" (Fitzgerald 73). Another piece of the puzzle of my suspicions is their drive to lunch. How exactly does Gatsby completely get off after being pulled over by just flashing a picture?
We then learn that Mr. Gatsby is just using Nick to get to his cousin, Daisy. The interesting and somewhat ironic part is that Mr. Gatsby has Jordan ask Nick about her instead of doing it himself. This seems like a pretty sly and untrustworthy guy to me. Mr. Gatsby is only interested in him so that he can set up a meeting with Gatsby and Daisy because they were lovers before he left for the war.
A few of the many things that i don't quite seem to understand is why, if Daisy loved Gatsby, did she marry Tom in the first place? and why is Tom that is cheating? She is the one that had a previous relationship that was very serious, but she has stayed faithful for their entire marriage?
We then learn that Mr. Gatsby is just using Nick to get to his cousin, Daisy. The interesting and somewhat ironic part is that Mr. Gatsby has Jordan ask Nick about her instead of doing it himself. This seems like a pretty sly and untrustworthy guy to me. Mr. Gatsby is only interested in him so that he can set up a meeting with Gatsby and Daisy because they were lovers before he left for the war.
A few of the many things that i don't quite seem to understand is why, if Daisy loved Gatsby, did she marry Tom in the first place? and why is Tom that is cheating? She is the one that had a previous relationship that was very serious, but she has stayed faithful for their entire marriage?
Gatsby 6 (pgs 60-72)
As chapter 4 of Fitzgerald's The Great Gatsby opens, there is more speculation as to what Gatsby does for a living, but there is still not any reasonable explanation. Immediately to follow, there seems to be a litany of people that attended parties in the past summer. Nick also seems to have an opinion/judgement of pretty much everyone that has attended the parties. This is a bit ironic considering his earlier statement
"Whenever you feel like criticizing any one,...just remember that all the people in this world haven't had the advantages that you've had" (Fitzgerald 1). If this is his philosophy, then how is it appropriate for him to have judgments of all these people??
We then get a little more of a background on Mr. Gatsby. He says that he went to Oxford, but this is suspicious according to Nick. He says, "He [Gatsby] hurried the phrase 'educated at oxford' or swallowed it, or choked on it, as though it bothered him before" (Fitzgerald 65) Why would Gatsby lie to him about his past? What does he have to hide? He also says that he lived in San Francisco where his family all died and he came in to a large sum of money. He then talks of his military accomplishments and gets a bit arrogant when he speaks of Montenegro and his medal from there.
Sunday, August 5, 2012
Gatsby 5 (pgs 51-59)
As the third chapter of The Great Gatsby comes to a close, it turns out that Gatsby did not invite Jordan up to see him alone. He actually invited her up to a room full of women who supposedly had fights with their husbands. Why she was there, I am not sure, but she was not there long.
Gatsby then comes back outside and converses with Nick to sure up their plans to hydroplane in the morning. We also then learn a little bit about Gatsby. As of now in the book, he has gotten two different calls one from Philadelphia and i do not remember the other city, but he must be a pretty important guy if he gets calls like this so frequently.
Jordan baker and Nick meet up again later in the summer and initially nick enjoys spending time with her, but that does not last. We learn that she is a compulsive liar, but Nick does not hold that against her at all. He says, "Dishonesty in a woman is a thing you never blame deeply..." (Fitzgerald 58). This is an interesting statement by Nick, and i have a feeling that Fitzgerald meant for it to have a deeper meaning that I am not aware of.
Gatsby then comes back outside and converses with Nick to sure up their plans to hydroplane in the morning. We also then learn a little bit about Gatsby. As of now in the book, he has gotten two different calls one from Philadelphia and i do not remember the other city, but he must be a pretty important guy if he gets calls like this so frequently.
Jordan baker and Nick meet up again later in the summer and initially nick enjoys spending time with her, but that does not last. We learn that she is a compulsive liar, but Nick does not hold that against her at all. He says, "Dishonesty in a woman is a thing you never blame deeply..." (Fitzgerald 58). This is an interesting statement by Nick, and i have a feeling that Fitzgerald meant for it to have a deeper meaning that I am not aware of.
Gatsby 4 (pgs 39-50)
As the third chapter of The Great Gatsby opens, Gatsby is preparing for what seems to be a huge party, and Nick gets an invitation from one of Gatsby's chauffeurs. To my surprise this party seems a lot like a bunch of college students on spring break. Another interesting part was that Gatsby did not know the majority of the guests, but he did not seem to mind.
As Nick and Jordan Baker begin to mingle and talk, Fitzgerald sets up some irony. The couple runs into a man that invites Nick to test out a hydroplane, because the man recognized Nick from the war. Nick then references Gatsby by name, and "for a moment he [Gatsby] looked at me as if he failed to understand. I'm Gatsby" (Fitzgerald 48). This caught Nick off guard because he was expecting Gatsby to be an older man and not a man about his age. After Gatsby excuses himself, they begin to speculate about where he is from and what he does for a living. Minutes later, Jordan is summoned to go see Gatsby by a butler and she is told to go alone. I wonder what will happen, does he like her? and why did he tell her to come alone?
As Nick and Jordan Baker begin to mingle and talk, Fitzgerald sets up some irony. The couple runs into a man that invites Nick to test out a hydroplane, because the man recognized Nick from the war. Nick then references Gatsby by name, and "for a moment he [Gatsby] looked at me as if he failed to understand. I'm Gatsby" (Fitzgerald 48). This caught Nick off guard because he was expecting Gatsby to be an older man and not a man about his age. After Gatsby excuses himself, they begin to speculate about where he is from and what he does for a living. Minutes later, Jordan is summoned to go see Gatsby by a butler and she is told to go alone. I wonder what will happen, does he like her? and why did he tell her to come alone?
Gatsby 3 (pgs 26-38)
As chapter two of The Great Gatsby begins to come to a close, Tom and Nick are put into an interesting situation. They go to see Mrs. Wilson, AKA Tom's mistress... However, they do not just go to see Mrs. Wilson, they go to Mr. Wilson's car garage to see Mrs. Wilson, and he was there! How much worse can a situation get? Mr. Wilson probably has no clue that the man he is buying a car from is having an affair with his wife, and they are meeting right under his nose! I am sorry, but in my opinion, that is disgusting. Unfortunate, it seems that i am right with my prediction that this will recur in this book much like it did in the last one.
We also learn a few things about the relationship between Mrs. Wilson and Tom. She gets what she wants, for example, "I want to get one of those dogs" (Fitzgerald 27). This happens while they are driving down the street in a cab, and what do they do? The only rational thing, stop, get out and buy the dog. This seems a bit crazy to me...but then again i am a relatively reasonable person...
We also learn a few things about the relationship between Mrs. Wilson and Tom. She gets what she wants, for example, "I want to get one of those dogs" (Fitzgerald 27). This happens while they are driving down the street in a cab, and what do they do? The only rational thing, stop, get out and buy the dog. This seems a bit crazy to me...but then again i am a relatively reasonable person...
Gatsby 2 (pgs 13-25)
I have a very unfortunate feeling that the theme of infidelity will again pop up in The Great Gatsby just like it did in The House of Mirth. When I read "Tom's got a woman in New York" (Fitzgerald 15), my initial reaction was oh great...more people that enjoy cheating on their spouses. However, I cant decide if his wife knows and is alright with it, or if she has no clue and will be completely blind sided by it...but only time will tell.
We also finally learn the narrator's name, but we learn his first and last name in two completely different parts of this section, which i found to be odd. Also, we learn that Nick fought in the war. I have a feeling that we will very slowly learn more about nick through the book, I don't think we will be given a paragraph that is a direct characterization of him.
Also in this section, on page 13, there was talk of the Nordic races and it is unclear to me which one of the Buchanans was telling of them, there are indications both ways. Regardless of who mentioned them, this almost seems comparable to a modern conspiracy theory.
I am starting to get a feel for Mrs. Buchanan's character when she says" I've been everywhere and seen everything and done everything" (Fitzgerald 17). I am sorry to burst her bubble, but no one has done that, there are always new things being created and always something new to see. I am going to venture a guess that she is very conceited and cocky.
We also finally learn the narrator's name, but we learn his first and last name in two completely different parts of this section, which i found to be odd. Also, we learn that Nick fought in the war. I have a feeling that we will very slowly learn more about nick through the book, I don't think we will be given a paragraph that is a direct characterization of him.
Also in this section, on page 13, there was talk of the Nordic races and it is unclear to me which one of the Buchanans was telling of them, there are indications both ways. Regardless of who mentioned them, this almost seems comparable to a modern conspiracy theory.
I am starting to get a feel for Mrs. Buchanan's character when she says" I've been everywhere and seen everything and done everything" (Fitzgerald 17). I am sorry to burst her bubble, but no one has done that, there are always new things being created and always something new to see. I am going to venture a guess that she is very conceited and cocky.
Gatsby 1 (pgs 1-12)
Right off the bat in The Great Gatsby, F. Scott Fitzgerald begins to make the reader think. When he says "Whenever you feel like criticizing any one,...just remember that all the people in this world haven't had the advantages that you've had" (Fitzgerald 1). This is very profound in my opinion and I predict that this will be a recurring theme in this book. Fitzgerald also uses some high level diction in the opening pages. For example, "snobbishly" and "unaffected scorn", and of which point to a target audience that has been well educated.
Later in the book when the narrator is describing Tom Buchanan, he says "Not even the effeminate swank of his riding clothes could hide the enormous power of that body" (Fitzgerald 7). It seems to me that the narrator is admiring Tom and he is somewhat jealous of him. However, the narrator then says "It was a body capable of enormous leverage-a cruel body"(Fitzgerald 7). At the beginning of this sentence, the narrator is still admiring him, but he then seems to switch his opinion very quickly by saying that he had a cruel body. I do not really have a feel for the narrator yet, considering that I am 12 pages in, but I am interested to see what kind of a character he is.
Later in the book when the narrator is describing Tom Buchanan, he says "Not even the effeminate swank of his riding clothes could hide the enormous power of that body" (Fitzgerald 7). It seems to me that the narrator is admiring Tom and he is somewhat jealous of him. However, the narrator then says "It was a body capable of enormous leverage-a cruel body"(Fitzgerald 7). At the beginning of this sentence, the narrator is still admiring him, but he then seems to switch his opinion very quickly by saying that he had a cruel body. I do not really have a feel for the narrator yet, considering that I am 12 pages in, but I am interested to see what kind of a character he is.
Sunday, July 8, 2012
Mirth Part 2 (XIII and XIV)
As Edith Wharton brings The House of Mirth to a close, Lily finally began to realize what a terrible life she created for herself. I attribute this to not listening to the advice that Gerty gave her over and over again. She also did not really have much common sense throughout the entire novel. I said it before and I will gladly say it again, Lily should have married Selden at the beginning of the novel when they both had feelings for each other. If she would have done so, she would have saved her self all the trouble she went through...and the book would have been considerably shorter!
I believe that throughout the book, Wharton did a fairly good job of keeping the reader engaged, with the exception of all the gossip about people that seemed as if it would never end. Although the title still does not make any sense to me and the ending was not at all what i was expecting, the book definitely was not bad!
But back to me not expecting the ending... I was under the assumption that this book was going to have the typical happy ending. I predicted that Lily was going to marry Selden and they would live happy ever after...Boy was i wrong! When Lily said "Tomorrow would not be so difficult at all: she felt sure she would have the strength to meet it" (Wharton 262), I knew that Darwin would be at work soon after she fell asleep.
Mirth part 2 (XI and XII)
As The House of Mirth draws to a close, Edith Wharton has inserted a HUGE turning point in the novel. When Lily went to Selden's residence and apologized for her previous actions at Mrs. Hatch's home she rid herself of most of her worries of that Selden thought of her. When she said "I wanted you to know that I left Mrs. Hatch immediately after I saw you...and i did that because you told me to" (Wharton 248), she finally showed me that she understood that he was the voice of reason. She also realized that he really knew what was best for her. I have learned at points in my life that someone with a perspective of the whole situation usually knows whats best. We get so focused on the here and now and we don't realize that what we are doing makes no sense. Lily was very much in this situation at Mrs. Hatch's.
After careful consideration I believe that when Selden "When she rose he fancied that he saw her draw something from her dress and drop it into the fire" (Wharton 252), he did see her actually place something into the fire. I believe that this "something" are the letters that she received from Rosedale's building. I was wondering about them when Mr. Rosedale popped back in a few sections ago...and here they are!
After careful consideration I believe that when Selden "When she rose he fancied that he saw her draw something from her dress and drop it into the fire" (Wharton 252), he did see her actually place something into the fire. I believe that this "something" are the letters that she received from Rosedale's building. I was wondering about them when Mr. Rosedale popped back in a few sections ago...and here they are!
Friday, July 6, 2012
Mirth Part 2 (IX and X)
As the action proceeds in The House of Mirth, Edith Wharton places Lily in an interesting change of setting. She moves her to a very upper class place in New York and Lily is employed as the personal secretary of Mrs. Norma Hatch. Ironically, this does not last long at all. Selden came and attempted to persuade Lily to come back to her friends and live with Gerty, but yet again Lily's selfish attributes kick in and she turns him down. According to Selden, Gerty is worried sick about her and really wants her to come back and stay with her...which again portrays her very strong selfless characteristics.
Considering Selden's latest interaction with Lily, I believe he has taken over the role as the voice of reason. Previously, I said that it was Gerty and i do still think that before this scenario, Gerty was the more reasonable of the two; however, Gerty does not really directly advise in this scenario.
I am also a bit confused as to the random sleeping pills that Lily seems to be addicted to. I realize that she can't sleep, but i have a feeling that they symbolize something more than just her "only hope of renewal" (Wharton 241). Another thing that has me confused is the random meeting with Rosedale. It seems like such an odd time for him to pop back in after hew as not mentioned for quite a while.
Considering Selden's latest interaction with Lily, I believe he has taken over the role as the voice of reason. Previously, I said that it was Gerty and i do still think that before this scenario, Gerty was the more reasonable of the two; however, Gerty does not really directly advise in this scenario.
I am also a bit confused as to the random sleeping pills that Lily seems to be addicted to. I realize that she can't sleep, but i have a feeling that they symbolize something more than just her "only hope of renewal" (Wharton 241). Another thing that has me confused is the random meeting with Rosedale. It seems like such an odd time for him to pop back in after hew as not mentioned for quite a while.
Mirth Part 2 (VII and VIII)
As The House of Mirth
continues, I have made an interesting observation. As the beginning chapters began to unfold,
Lily’s reason for not marrying Selden was because of his lack of money. As the novel continues currently, Lily is
losing money by the day, and she is nearly poor, she is pretty much alone and still
seeking a husband with money. My
question is wouldn’t it have been easier to marry Selden when the two of them
were in love instead of going through all this?
Yes, she wouldn’t have a lavish lifestyle in the future, but she would be
better off than she is now. It just doesn’t
make any sense to me…
Another recurring theme has become prevalent in this
section. This theme would be selfishness
on the part of Lily Bart. She went to
see Gerty when she is distraught, and this is one of the things she said to her,
“You stupid dear, why do you say such odious things to me? It’s enough to make
one ill to be told one looks so…” (Wharton 215). This doesn’t sound like something that I would
say to a friend listening to my problems.
Time and time again, Gerty looks out for Lily and she just keeps being a
selfish jerk to her. Again, this just doesn’t
make any sense to me…
Mirth part 2 (V and VI)
To open the fifth section of the second book in The House of Mirth, Edith Wharton has deployed some interesting symbolism that i believe has a very deep meaning. She started out by saying "It seemed to Lily, as Mrs. Peniston's door closed on her, that she was taking a final leave of her old life" (Wharton 187). Not only has Lily left her old home, she has essentially left behind her family and most of her old friends. She was literally seeking a new start to her life because the old life she had was so horrid. I believe this was a HUGE turning point in Lily's life and the novel, she went from her old "mirthless" life, to a new life that seems to be full of "mirth"!
Gerty continued with her selfless behavior, which i find to be another recurring theme in the novel. Time after time Gerty has set aside whatever her problems or worries were and helped not only Lily, but Selden too! Gerty has also played the role of the voice of reason for Lily throughout their entire friendship! In light of this "voice of reason" i feel like there is going to be another interesting twist because Gerty so adamantly told Lily not to go on her Alaska trip and not to befriend the Gormer's like she has done. At this point, she is so dependent on them and their circle of friends that if something were to go wrong, it would have to be a catastrophic failure much like what happened in the Trenor friendship.
Gerty continued with her selfless behavior, which i find to be another recurring theme in the novel. Time after time Gerty has set aside whatever her problems or worries were and helped not only Lily, but Selden too! Gerty has also played the role of the voice of reason for Lily throughout their entire friendship! In light of this "voice of reason" i feel like there is going to be another interesting twist because Gerty so adamantly told Lily not to go on her Alaska trip and not to befriend the Gormer's like she has done. At this point, she is so dependent on them and their circle of friends that if something were to go wrong, it would have to be a catastrophic failure much like what happened in the Trenor friendship.
Mirth part 2 (III and IV)
As the drama continues in The House of Mirth, Edith Wharton has thrown in a few unexpected twists, some of which are quite ironic. To start the third section, Selden and Mr. Dorset meet to supposedly draw up divorce papers, but that never actually happened. Instead, Lily got kicked off the Dorset's boat and was left in Europe. Somehow, Lily found her way back with the help of Selden and the Stepneys.
Another shocking twist was the death of Mrs. Peniston. The slightly ironic part is that Lily did not hear the news from a relative, but from Gerty. Usually, the family knows of the death of a loved one before acquaintances and friends...i found this to be a little odd, but on the other hand, Lily's family does not seem to be too fond of her in the first place. Lastly, as the attorneys gathered to execute the will, no one there was worried about the death of their beloved aunt, they were all worried entirely too much about how much money they would receive. To everyone's surprise..."to my niece Lily Bart ten thousand dollars...and the residue of my estate to my dear cousin and name-sake, Grace Julia Stepney" (Wharton 180). Literally everyone thought that Lily would get the entire estate including the house, but she got enough money to pay off her debt...just a bit ironic.
In a later conversation between Grace and Lily, Grace said "it was the idea of your being in debt that brought on her illness"(Wharton 186). Which would explain the rewriting of the will just six weeks before her death, and why Lily's inheritance seems a bit smaller that expected.
Another shocking twist was the death of Mrs. Peniston. The slightly ironic part is that Lily did not hear the news from a relative, but from Gerty. Usually, the family knows of the death of a loved one before acquaintances and friends...i found this to be a little odd, but on the other hand, Lily's family does not seem to be too fond of her in the first place. Lastly, as the attorneys gathered to execute the will, no one there was worried about the death of their beloved aunt, they were all worried entirely too much about how much money they would receive. To everyone's surprise..."to my niece Lily Bart ten thousand dollars...and the residue of my estate to my dear cousin and name-sake, Grace Julia Stepney" (Wharton 180). Literally everyone thought that Lily would get the entire estate including the house, but she got enough money to pay off her debt...just a bit ironic.
In a later conversation between Grace and Lily, Grace said "it was the idea of your being in debt that brought on her illness"(Wharton 186). Which would explain the rewriting of the will just six weeks before her death, and why Lily's inheritance seems a bit smaller that expected.
Thursday, July 5, 2012
Mirth part 2 (I and II)
As book two of The House of Mirth begins to unfold, Edith Wharton has a very interesting setting change. The interesting part is that both Seldon and Lily leave and head west and somehow Lily finds herself at yet another gambling hot spot. According to Wharton, "...the accident of placing the Atlantic between herself and her obligations made them dwindle out of sight..." (Wharton 158), so apparently she has no intention of paying the debts back? i guess we will find out soon enough... Seldon and Lily see each other for a short while, but never really spoke much, which i say to be ironic considering the fact that Lily still had to confess all of her failures. Another recurring theme is this somewhat random adultery. In earlier chapters there had been rumors about Lily and a few other men...only one of which was married, but now Mrs. Dorset invites Lily on their Mediterranean getaway to distract her husband. Mrs. Dorset was having an affair with Ned Silverton, but she was spreading rumors about Mr. Dorset (her own husband) and Lily having an affair. The irony only continues when George wants to summon Seldon to draw up divorce papers. Of course Lily was opposed to the idea because it didn't make her look the best...but all of a sudden, she was fine with it. All of these affairs and couples have me very confused. Also, whatever happened to Mr. Gyce? i realize that he got married, but did he also just fall off the face of the earth??
Mirth part 1 (XIV and XV)
The interesting comparisons continue in the end of book one of The House of Mirth. Edith Wharton began the fourteenth section with a comparison between Gerty Farish and and a fly. She did so by saying "Gerty had always been a parasite in the moral order, living on the crumbs of other tables, and content to look through the window at the banquet spread for her friends" (Wharton 121). It is a crude comparison and i bit of a demoralizing one for Gerty, but it is very accurate. She is always in the shadows...except when Seldon or Lily needs to talk about their problems. Seldon attended dinner at Gerty's house to discuss his love for
Lily, but he has yet to notice that his own cousin has romantic feelings for him. Which that in itself is a little creepy, in my opinion...but still, they all ignore Gerty until they need to vent to her. The same thing happened when Lily stopped by Gerty's on the way home from the Trenor's. Gerty was practically in tears and Lily did not seem to notice at all...she just went on with her complaining about how she messed up and she wanted Seldon to love her. This situation is quite ironic because Gerty is in the center of all of this and Lily and Seldon have no clue...
The situation when Seldon sees Lily leaving the Trenor's house is also very ironic. Seldon knew nothing about the situation, but he took what he saw and immediately thought of the worst possibly outcome. He literally had nothing to go on except Lily getting into a cab and Gus running back inside and somehow...he assumes that Lily is having an affair. When will he figure out that he is wrong? When will Lily and Seldon figure out about Gerty?
Lily, but he has yet to notice that his own cousin has romantic feelings for him. Which that in itself is a little creepy, in my opinion...but still, they all ignore Gerty until they need to vent to her. The same thing happened when Lily stopped by Gerty's on the way home from the Trenor's. Gerty was practically in tears and Lily did not seem to notice at all...she just went on with her complaining about how she messed up and she wanted Seldon to love her. This situation is quite ironic because Gerty is in the center of all of this and Lily and Seldon have no clue...
The situation when Seldon sees Lily leaving the Trenor's house is also very ironic. Seldon knew nothing about the situation, but he took what he saw and immediately thought of the worst possibly outcome. He literally had nothing to go on except Lily getting into a cab and Gus running back inside and somehow...he assumes that Lily is having an affair. When will he figure out that he is wrong? When will Lily and Seldon figure out about Gerty?
Mirth part 1 (XII and XIII)
Continuing on in The House of Mirth by Edith Wharton, I have noticed a very large change in Lily's character. Primarily her change in her attitude towards Gerty. Yes, it began before this section, but at the end of the thirteenth section i find it to be very strong. On her way home from Gus Trenor's house, Lily says this as she sees Gerty's house approaching the cab, "Gerty!-they were nearing Gerty's corner...if only she could feel the hold of Gerty's arms while she shook the ague-fit of fear that was coming on her" (Wharton 121). She went from calling her weird and disliking her when she first met Seldon to wanting her to comfort her much like a best friend would! I would say that this is a good example of a dynamic character because i believe events form the story sparked this change. Another dynamic character that has shown his face again in this section is Gus Trenor. He has always seemed to have feelings for Lily, but they always seemed more friendly than anything else, to me. However, near the end of the thirteenth section, he tells her that he is tired of her playing with his emotions, but i don't think she felt like she was emotionally involved at all, nor did i get the sense that she ever thought that. I always got the sense that Lily was just wanting to be good friends with him much like she was with his wife, and the investment advice was just a benefit to the friendship.
Wednesday, July 4, 2012
Mirth part 1 (X and XI)
In section X of The House of Mirth by Edith Wharton, there seems to be a new theme coming about. Lily seems to be in quite a forgiving mood, especially while she is with Mr. Rosedale. She essentially forgave Gus without even confronting him about telling their secrets. Also, later in the tenth section, instead of disposing of the letters, she was satisfied with just possessing them. The narrator states "If she had destroyed Mrs. Dorset's letters, she might have continued to hate her; but the fact that they remained in her possession had fed her resentment to satisfy" (Wharton 97). I thought she would destroy them out of resentment, but apparently she has had a slight change of heart. Lily also seems to be in a giving mood when she sees Miss Gerty Farish and they discuss her philanthropic events.
Wharton also made another odd comparison in the eleventh section of the novel. She compared Grace Stephney's mind to "a moral fly paper" and she said "the buzzing items of gossip are drawn by a fatal attraction"(Wharton 99). This is a very creative comparison, also it is extremely accurate thus far. She is almost some sort of an omniscient listener, if that makes any sense?
Wharton also made another odd comparison in the eleventh section of the novel. She compared Grace Stephney's mind to "a moral fly paper" and she said "the buzzing items of gossip are drawn by a fatal attraction"(Wharton 99). This is a very creative comparison, also it is extremely accurate thus far. She is almost some sort of an omniscient listener, if that makes any sense?
Mirth part 1 (VIII and IX)
At the beginning of section VIII in Edith Wharton's The House of Mirth, Lily goes from thinking she might be in love with Seldon to never wanting to see him again. Wharton said " She did not wish to see him again, not because she feared his influence, but because his presence always had the effect of cheapening her aspirations, of throwing her whole world out of focus" (Wharton 71). So all of the sudden, Lily's character has encountered a huge change. I am not quite sure how she makes such a drastic change so fast, but on the other side of her romantic world, Mr. Gryce is now engaged. That in itself is puzzling. His character was portrayed as such a shy and reserved guy and he went out and got engaged to someone in a matter of a few weeks? I am sure there is more to this guy, but I do not even have a guess as to what.
Less than ten pages later, Wharton writes "She longed to be to him something more than a piece of silent prettiness, a passing diversion to his eye and brain..." (Wharton 76). This is referring to the relationship between Seldon and Lily, yet again. This has me quite confused. This is a bit like the game "She loves me, she loves me not" that people played with a daisy! I realize that the comparison might be a bit crude, but she is just changing her feelings for this guy on what seems to me to be a whim. Maybe there is some piece of information that i did not pick up on that completes the puzzle??
Mirth part 1 (VI and VII)
In sections VI and VII of The House of Mirth, Edith Wharton has some very odd comparisons. She began with juxtaposing Seldon's sensations with the haze in the air. She does so by saying "In his own mind there was only a lazy sense of pleasure, veiling the sharp edges of sensation as the September haze veiled the scene at their feet"(Wharton 51). This is a very interesting comparison because it gives me a sense that Seldon is unsure of what he is feeling at the present moment. During the same scenario, Lily begins to question whether it is love she is experiencing love, or merely infatuation. I wonder if Seldon's sensations are similar to Lily's, but he just does not recognize what these sensations mean?
At a later point, Seldon compares Lily to an artist and himself to the colors she is using at the present moment. By this, I think he is saying that she is in control and he merely sees himself as a puppet or even a tool to craft her fate.
About mid way through part VI, Wharton shows the contrasting views of the meaning of success between Seldon and Lily. Lily believes that success is "to get as much as one can out of life" and Seldon very simply said "personal freedom"(Wharton 54). I have to say that i had an expectation very similar to Lily's definition, but Seldon's shocked me a bit. I did not really have a full sense of his character until this point, but i honestly did not expect such a simple and practical answer from him. Will this simplicity and practicality be a recurring theme with him?
At a later point, Seldon compares Lily to an artist and himself to the colors she is using at the present moment. By this, I think he is saying that she is in control and he merely sees himself as a puppet or even a tool to craft her fate.
About mid way through part VI, Wharton shows the contrasting views of the meaning of success between Seldon and Lily. Lily believes that success is "to get as much as one can out of life" and Seldon very simply said "personal freedom"(Wharton 54). I have to say that i had an expectation very similar to Lily's definition, but Seldon's shocked me a bit. I did not really have a full sense of his character until this point, but i honestly did not expect such a simple and practical answer from him. Will this simplicity and practicality be a recurring theme with him?
Mirth part 1 (IV and V)
As I continued reading, I have found that Edith Wharton began to give me the sense that Lily looks at this whole endeavor as some sort of a performance or maybe even a game. Lily says " I have to calculate and contrive, and retreat and advance, as if i were going through an intricate dance, where one misstep would throw me hopelessly out of time" (Wharton 38).
In section V, The word "mirth" is mentioned. Merriam-Webster defines mirth as "gladness or gaiety as shown by or accompanied with laughter" (http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/mirth), but ironically, The House of Mirth seems pretty "mirthless" at this juncture.
The primary theme that seems to be recurring is materialism. However, this time it is Lily's view of Selden. She says "...she had been to busy with her own affairs to regard him as more than one of the plesant accessories of life" (Wharton 43). Another theme that has popped up again is the self absorbed characters. For the majority of this section, Lily has been gossiping about people, worrying about that Selden and Mr. Gryce think about her, and worrying about what everyone else is doing. In the spirit of the title of the book, wouldn't laughter with friends and a fun time be more appropriate? I am very confused as to how the title applies to the book. As of now, the title "The house of no Mirth" would be much more appropriate.
In section V, The word "mirth" is mentioned. Merriam-Webster defines mirth as "gladness or gaiety as shown by or accompanied with laughter" (http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/mirth), but ironically, The House of Mirth seems pretty "mirthless" at this juncture.
The primary theme that seems to be recurring is materialism. However, this time it is Lily's view of Selden. She says "...she had been to busy with her own affairs to regard him as more than one of the plesant accessories of life" (Wharton 43). Another theme that has popped up again is the self absorbed characters. For the majority of this section, Lily has been gossiping about people, worrying about that Selden and Mr. Gryce think about her, and worrying about what everyone else is doing. In the spirit of the title of the book, wouldn't laughter with friends and a fun time be more appropriate? I am very confused as to how the title applies to the book. As of now, the title "The house of no Mirth" would be much more appropriate.
Tuesday, July 3, 2012
Mirth part 1 (III)
In the third section of Edith Wharton's The House of Mirth, She begins by portraying Lily Bart's search for a husband as a game. This is evident when she says " but she had neither the skill nor the patience to effect his capture." (Wharton 19). Lily is not trying to find someone to marry that she loves, but someone that will be able to financially support the lavish lifestyle she desires to live. This desire to have such a man comes from her own family. Wharton says later that Lily could not remember a time when there was an abundance of money in their household (Wharton 23). Lily does not want to be placed in this situation again.
Throughout the flashback in the novel, Lily's mother seems to have ingrained in her that being dingy or having dingy things is never acceptable. I believe that Lily's materialistic views that i discussed in an earlier post stem from this. She was taught from a young age that money is what matters, and this is why i believe Ms. Bart will end up choosing Mr. Gryce over Selden. Despite the fact that she is bored to death with everything Mr. Gryce has to say, Selden just does not have the money to make Lily "happy".
Monday, July 2, 2012
Mirth part 1 (I and II)
Within the first page of Edith Warton's The House of Mirth, I began to grasp an understanding for the character of Ms. Lily Bart. She seems very concerned with how she is viewed by other people. She also has very intelligent and deep observations; however, i believe she over analyzes most scenarios. I would say the adjective materialistic could be used to describe her as well.
Also within the first page of part one, when Selden sees Ms. Bart at the train station there is a little bit of foreshadowing. " It struck him at once that she was waiting for someone, but he hardly knew why the idea arrested him" (Wharton 1). She is not necessarily waiting for someone that very second, but she is waiting to find a man to marry her.
As I read into part two, I got a sense that Warton uses the image of clothing to describe how men view women. I found evidence of this when Warton said "If i were shabby no one would have me: a woman is asked out as much for her clothes as for herself. The clothes are the background, the frame, if you like: they don't make success, but they are a part of it. Who wants a dingy woman?" (Wharton 13). In my opinion she is trying to substitute clothing for women. This leads back to my comment about materialism, so maybe the material ism is not only Ms. Bart, but society in general?
Also within the first page of part one, when Selden sees Ms. Bart at the train station there is a little bit of foreshadowing. " It struck him at once that she was waiting for someone, but he hardly knew why the idea arrested him" (Wharton 1). She is not necessarily waiting for someone that very second, but she is waiting to find a man to marry her.
As I read into part two, I got a sense that Warton uses the image of clothing to describe how men view women. I found evidence of this when Warton said "If i were shabby no one would have me: a woman is asked out as much for her clothes as for herself. The clothes are the background, the frame, if you like: they don't make success, but they are a part of it. Who wants a dingy woman?" (Wharton 13). In my opinion she is trying to substitute clothing for women. This leads back to my comment about materialism, so maybe the material ism is not only Ms. Bart, but society in general?
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
